Graphic Heroics: The Anti-Pretension Machine, Part 1
Posted by Luke Forney on Jul 11, 2011 in News | 6 commentsMore and more, modern comics and graphic novels seem to get wrapped up in a sense of literary pretension. Whether it is a litany of “This is a graphic novel, but it’s okay because its literary,” or “This graphical novel is bad because it lacks literary merit,” literary snobbery seems to be on the rise with this growing literary art form. Not that “literary” graphic fiction is bad; far from it, it has helped the genre grow, and presented some of its truest classics, from Neil Gaiman’s Sandman to Frank Miller’s Sin City, or Watchman, V for Vendetta, From Hell, or most anything else by Alan Moore (my personal favorite Moore is his run on Swamp Thing). Yet, that is only a part of what the genre has to offer. So, focusing on heroic fiction within graphic/comic literature, here is the beginning of the anti-pretension project, focusing on the least “literary,” and most downright fun, that heroic graphic fiction has to offer.

Westerns…and Aliens
Outside of Lonesome Dove, not many Westerns are lauded for their greatness, yet the popularity of the genre can’t be for no reason whatsoever. Yet, if we take Westerns, we can add the one element that is even less “literary,” aliens, and what do we get? The upcoming blockbuster film, Cowboys & Aliens, based on the 2006 graphic novel, created by Scott Mitchell Rosenburg, written by the brilliant Fred Van Lent with Andrew Foley, and penciled by Luciano Lima. Cowboys & Aliens is a wonderfully fun idea, with strong heroic characters and a fast-paced plot. Fans of westerns are hard pressed to find good graphic fiction (one exception is Gus & His Gang by Christophe Blain), and science fiction is growing into a market dominated by superheroics, but to find both together is a true treat.
Captain America
Captain America: The First Avenger is racing to movie theaters, and the availability of work on the unabashedly patriotic and brightly-costumed hero is at an all-time high. Ed Brubaker (whose run can be found conveniently in Captain America Omnibus, Volume 1) had a very extensive run on the hero’s book, making huge changes that are impacting the character years later. Cap has also been featuring in multiple Avengers titles (check out his role in the hardcover New Avengers, Vol. 1), and has been key in all of the major Marvel events, from House of M to Civil War to Secret Invasion. New readers might jump on with the just-relaunched Avengers, or check out Avengers Prime for a more traditional Avengers book. A new all-ages Captain America book is also available, Captain America: The Fighting Avenger.

Manhwa
Never heard of manhwa before? Neither have most people. This is digging deep into the “non-literary” bin. Manhwa is a style of South Korean comic art. If it helps to think of it, manhwa is to South Korea as manga is to Japan: a very popular, country-wide prominent comic art style. A popular creator of manhwa is Hyung Min-woo, who is currently achieving an increase in popularity state-side for his comic Priest, which inspired the recent movie of the same name starring Paul Bettany. While some of the earlier volumes have gone out of print, TokyoPop has recently released Priest: Genesis, an omnibus collecting the first three volumes of the series. At a very decent price, this is the perfect jumping on point to the series, which is an engaging tale in its own right, as well as being a neat foray into a story from a region of the world that isn’t well-known for its literary output here in the United States.
Next time, in The Anti-Pretension Machine, Part 2, we will address other “less literary” masterpieces, such as Ed Brubaker’s Rise and Fall of the Shi’ar Empire, some fantasy content, and a new work by the estimable Steve Niles, known for his breakout vampire hit, 30 Days of Night. See you then!


Cowboys & Aliens was excellent. I really hope the film doesn’t suck.
Though I confess I’ve never been able to enjoy Alan Moore’s comics, mostly because of his predilection for intensely weird sex. Reading his work was, for me, somewhat like visiting a public restroom – you always come away feeling a bit unclean.
I think that’s why I enjoyed his run on Swamp Thing more than any of his other titles: it had the weird sex (inescapable), but it was a very, very minor plot point, and it actually had relevance to the plot in a pretty significant way. After racking my brain, I think that the first volume of The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen is free from weird sex, and is a pretty stand-alone tale. However, it wasn’t my favorite of his works, and I didn’t feel compelled to pick up the second volume (which has the odd love-interest pairing of Allan Quatermain and Mina Murry).
Great article, Luke. “Graphic heroes”…sounds much more grown-up than comic book heroes, etc. There is nothing “comic” about many of the heroes written and illustrated today…which is fine for us adults who want to read gritty action-adventure tales of the graphic/illustrated type be they star-spangled uniform-wearing types or otherwise.
PRIEST looks enticing. Will have to check it out.
COWBOYS & ALIENS just looks…fun. I want to see it.
Again, great article.
Thanks for the kind words. “Graphic Heroics” seemed like a nice, broad way to approach the topic, in case I wanted to stretch past comics/graphic novels a bit… that, and the Dark Horse Conan isn’t exactly all ages friendly.
Thisis a great post for me. I’ve just started reading graphic novels after many many years away from comics. The Watchmen got me started, but I’ve also read quite a bit of lame stuff too so this is a nice guide.
If you are looking for something in particular, feel free to tell me some of your interests and I can see if I can steer you towards some titles you might like. Glad you returned to the dark side!